what is better Lauki juice or eating bioled lauki or eating raw lauki (31-mar-2015) No.5

March 31, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152689678526922

what is better Lauki juice or eating bioled lauki or eating raw lauki ?
.
Some say juice is best. any reasons why?
.
Wont boiled lauki be better than juice?

"swa" means "my" NOT "ours" ( as per ArKe ) (31-mar-2015) No.4

March 31, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152689800776922

"swa" means "my" NOT "ours"

( as per ArKe )

Green cap Red cap booth level meetings (30-mar-2015) No.5

March 30, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152688130726922

Green cap Red cap booth level meetings --- Green cap means speaker can speak , red cap means speaker should stop speaking
.
IMO, activists should work to hold green cap red cap meetings at their booth level. The caps dont have any affiliation with party etc. They are just like traffic lights.
.
1. say meeting of 1 , 2 or 3 (not more) booths are called . Booth is list of 500-800 voters in a voter list.
.
2. The attendees will be divided into 4 separate groups.
.
(1a) male voters of those booths and spouses of female voters in those booths
.
(1b) female voters of those booths and spouses of male voters of those booths.
.
(1c) male attendee who are NOT voters in those booths nor spouses of any female voters in those booths.
.
(1d) female male attendee who are NOT voters in those booths nor spouses of any male voter in those booths.
.
2. Each person will have to buy red cap and green cap or he may bring his own.
.
3. The organizers will need voter list to ensure that everyone in group (1a) and (1b) are voters or spouses of voters.
.
4. The organizer will use dices to select a random number between 1 and number of voters in that booth. And voter selected will give name of 1 speaker, Those who want that speaker to speak will immediately wear green cap and those who dont will wear red cap.Those who dont want to vote will wear no cap.
.
5. Those who have worn green cap will move on right and stand in queue of 10. And those who have worn red will come on left and stand in queue of 10. And thus counting will become fast.
.
6. Like that 5 voters will be chosen at random and each will suggest one speaker. Ad the speaker who gets highest greens will speak
.
7. Those who want speaker to end will wear red cap and those who wish that he should continue will wear green cap. And when red outnumber green, the speaker will have to end the speech. The speaker can suggest a name when he ends his speech.
.
8. So there are 4 speakers on whom red-green count is known. And one more was suggested by speaker. red-green count will be taken on him,
,
9. The one with green count will speak.
.
There are several variations. But what it means is that speaker will have to end when audience wants to hear someone else. How to select that "someone" else? Again, red-green count can be used.
.
The count of ONLY voters in the booths will be counted and NOT others who are attending (WHY?). The others who are attending may wear red-green cap. But they will NOT be counted in deciding if speaker should speak or end.
.
So control remains with audience on whom audience wants to speak and whom audience wants to shut up.
.
If control remains with audience, then speakers will restrain himself from wasting audience's time.
.
=========================
.
Splitting of sabha
.
If certain voters think that other voters are ganging up or acting unfairly, then they can always call a meeting amongst themselves at later time and date.
.
======================
.
Later , a few variations can be made to decide "who should speak" via audience.
.
I will soon start such red-green-cap meetings in ahmedabad. lets see how it goes.

RSS-apex claims that BJP-MPs may be corrupt , but their 2500 Parcharaks are large non-corrupt (30-mar-2015) No.3

March 30, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152688132981922

RSS-apex claims that BJP-MPs may be corrupt , but their 2500 Parcharaks are large non-corrupt. So why didnt NaMo give tickets to 400 Pracharaks out of those 2500 Pracharaks?
.
And what sort of people are they, that they dont want to contest elections even it that is dire need of nation?
.
BJP had fielded 400 candidates in LS-2014 elections and some reaming 150 were fielded by NDA allies. NaMo / Bhagwat had power to give ticket ONLY to RSS-pracharaks if they wanted. But less than 10-20 pracharaks got tickets. And rest of the 380 tickets went to
.
The reason why NaMo / Bhagwat didnt give tickets to 400 Pracharaks is simple
.
1. Out of 400 , some 290-300 would have won, and within 3-4 months, over 80% would have become corrupt.
.
2. And that would have been end of RSS's prestige.and lakhs of RSS-volunteers will leave RSS and start alternate political alternatives and BJP's votes will move to new alternatives RSS-workers create.
.
RSS-apex retains influence in its members by claiming that "see, it is those BJP MPs who are defunct ; we RSS-apex and RSS-middle are all 100% non-corrupt and INCORRUPTIBLE !!". It is fact that 2500 RSS-pracharaks are non-corrupt because they dont have power. Well, even Laloo was non-corrupt when he didnt have power !! But the illusion they give is is "RSS-pracharaks are all INCORRUPTIBLE and when they get power Ram Rajya will come in India !!". And this hope is used to keep lakhs of members glued to RSS-apex and NOT start any political alternative.
.
And to keep their middle non-corrupt, they need to keep their middle away from political power !!
.
All in all, RSS-apex and BJP-apex has convinced them NOT to look beyond BJP , because one day 100s of RSS-pracharaks will become BJP MPs and bring Ram Rajya in India !!!
.
But fact that they didnt give MP tickets to 400 RSS-pracharaks who are INCORRUPTIBLE shows that it is something else.
.

Why PSUs , Army , DRDO etc dont take campus interview at IITs and other apex collges etc (30-mar-2015) No.2

March 30, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152688382556922

Why PSUs , Army , DRDO etc dont take campus interview at IITs and other apex collges etc?
.
Supreme Court has instructed all PSUs that they must recruit ALL staff after giving newspaper advt and taking exams or interviews of all those who apply. 
.
The judgment has some merit that PSUs must treat every candidate equally. 
.
What DRDO etc can do is take a mock competitive tests inside IIT etc and give cash rewards for those who pass. And based on the results of the students, they can tell students their chances of getting recruited in DRDO if they were to apply in the real test. And DRDO etc can also announce high rewards for all those who come in say top 200 in their actual tests, whether they join or not. And DRDO should also give advertisements in IIT's internal student's magazines etc when tests are due.
.
And this applies for not just IITs , but a large number of good colleges, where almost every student gets absorbed in campus interview . Here in employer *will* have to take efforts to reach to the students.
.
This will increase interest of students of apex colleges in all PSUs.
.

Dr NaMo orders BJP MP Dilip Gandhi , who heads Parliamentary Committee on Health to give medical advice (30-mar-2015) No.1

March 30, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152688388546922

Dr NaMo orders BJP MP Dilip Gandhi , who heads Parliamentary Committee on Health to give medical advice --- that there isnt any study linking cancer and smoking cigarette !!!
.
http://www.ndtv.com/…/no-indian-study-links-cigarettes-with…
.
If you have any proofs that Dr NaMo didnt order BJP MP Dilip Gandhi to say so, please provide evidences on YOUR wall.

Nathubhai Godse had left RSS in 1940 and joined Hindu Rashtra Dal (31-mar-2015) No.3

March 31, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152688418346922

Nathubhai Godse had left RSS in 1940 and joined Hindu Rashtra Dal . Why? No one knows --- but many say that Nathubhai considered RSS as timepass
.
I am anti-Nathibhai. He should have spent time, money, energy and life in exposing paidmedia that made Duratma Gandhi a Mahatma. His short only ended up increasing life of Gandhism. If Duratma gandhi had lived for just 2 more years, Gandhism would have died.
.
But many RSSians claim credit. Well, let them. But I do want all to note that Nathibhai had left RSS in 1940 !!! Why? There is no written reason he gave (that I know of). But many say that he consider RSS as timepass !!!
.
RSS-apex was heavily aided by the then kings , such as Scindhia of Gwalior !! Why would British agents like Scindhia aid RSS-apex ? Because Hindi Mahasabha was asking youth to become political. And British needed someone to convince youth to focus on character building etc etc and NOT become political !! Duratma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Ghazi were running Ashrams and Seval Dal to convince youth to stay away from politics !!! But they werent able to impress Hinduvaadi youth. British needed "Hinduvaadi" leaders to tell youth to stay away from politics !! And so British ask schindhia etc to aid RSS-apex.
.
Today, also, RSS-apex asks its volunteers to stay away form politics. This stops volunteers from working on a REAL nationalist political alternative in India. And when election come, RSS-apex will ask all workers to work for BJP by showing them threat "see, if you dont support BJP then Congress will win and will ruin Hindus !!!!". So between elections, RSS-apex keeps volunteers busy with morning walks and blood bank to drain away their energy, so that they cant form any political alternative. And just 3 months before election, RSS-apex will tell the ovious that "BJP is only alternative to congress !!"
.
All in all, RSS-apex now gives stability and votes to BJP and nothing more. The downside is that billions of activists hours , which should be used ONLY to create TRUE nationalist political alternatives, get wasted away,.
.
Solution?
.
Solution is that I ask ALL RSS-volunteers to discuss law-drafts needed to reduce corruption , nepotism in judiciary , use wealth tax instead of gst, etc . And you will see the picture.

Yatha karyakarta , tatha niyam (31-mar-2015) No.2

March 31, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152689404411922

Yatha karyakarta , tatha niyam
.
Yatha niyam , tatha raja , tatha praja.
.
Means "nature of activists will decide nature of law-drafts in a country. And nature of law-drafts will decide nature of both people and rulers".
.
IOW, both statements that "yatha raja , tatha praja" and "yatha praja , tatha raja" are incorrect. They both impact each other --- but much much less than the impact law-drafts cause on both.
.
And law-drafts come not due to efforts of rulers or career intellectuals or "career activists" or citizens at large. Rulers, career intellectuals, career activists and citizens on their own ONLY bring minor changes in what ever law-drafts that already exist. The new law-drafts come MAINLY due to efforts of "non career" activists, provided these "non career" activists work to bring the law-drafts.
.
The activist also comes from population at large, but difference is that he is willing to put a few hours a week of his time, his own money etc in something with no expectation. .
.
The activists in 950 AD and later in 110 AD in UK worked to bring JurySys in UK. This brought many other changes , such as direct election of London School Board members in 1840 and many more, and strengthened UK to a point that they captured half the world. USA went several steps ahead and printed law-drafts for elected officials such as police chiefs / judges / public prosecutors , right to recall , stronger jury system , referendum etc and became so strong that it controls almost whole world (including India).
.
So solution to mess in India I propose is ---- "true activists" i.e. "non career activists" should focus on law-drafts , publciize the law-drafts and ask citizens to oppose all leaders who refuse to support these law-drafts. As the leaders weaken, they will run to bring this very law-drafts they opposed and also run to claim credit for bringing them. OR , their sponsors will appoint new career leaders who will claim that they brought these law-drafts and NOT the activists !!! But if activists publicize the ;law-drafts, then they can force leaders and their sponsors to print those law-drafts in Gazette against their will.

The proposal of MRCM was also proposed by Thomas Paine and Thomas Jefferson (31-mar-2015) No.1

March 31, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152689485576922

The proposal of MRCM was also proposed by Thomas Paine and Thomas Jefferson.
.
Thomas Paine in 1780 / 1790 / 1805 wrote essay called "Agrarian Justice" . Please google on agrarian justice,. In the essay he said that some 10% inheritance tax should be imposed on LAND , and the money should be divided DIRECTLY amongst all americans equally !!! 
.
The reason he gave was --- LAND , and not outcomes of labor, is inherently public property and privatization of land was "unethical" , and this inheritance tax and equal division of inheritance tax would lessen it. 
.
Here are some quotes from Agraian Justice
.
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Agrarian_Justice 
.
"[10] It is a position not to be controverted that the earth, in its natural, uncultivated state was, and ever would have continued to be, the common property of the human race. In that state every man would have been born to property. He would have been a joint life proprietor with rest in the property of the soil, and in all its natural productions, vegetable and animal."
.
He gives example of how his inheritance tax model will work wrt England (because back then, the data was available only for England and not USA).
.
"[34] Mr. Pitt states the national capital of England, real and personal, to one thousand three hundred millions sterling,....
.
[35] The thirtieth part of this capital of £ 1,300,000,000 is £ 43,333,333 which is the part that will revolve every year by deaths in that country to new possessors; .. From this sum of £ 43,333,333 annually revolving, is be subtracted the value of the natural inheritance absorbed in it, which, perhaps, in fair justice, cannot be taken at less, and ought not be taken for more, than a tenth part.".
.
And Thomas Paine proposes that each person should get 10 pounds from this.
.
"Fund annually ............................................... £ 5,666,666 
To 400,000 aged persons at £ 10 each ......... £ 4,000,000 
To 90,000 persons of 21 yrs., £ 15 each....... £ 1,350,000 
-----------
£ 5,350,000 
-----------
Remains: £ 316,666 "
.
=====
.
Concept of MRCM applies on minerals, spectru and public land and NOT private land. But Thomas Jefferson goes one step ahead and applies the concept on private land as well !!! 
.
====================
.
Thomas Jefferson says , see http://famguardian.org/…/Polit…/thomasjefferson/jeff1550.htm .
.
"It is a moot question whether the origin of any kind of property is derived from nature at all... It is agreed by those who have seriously considered the subject that NO individual has, of natural right, a separate property in an acre of land, for instance. By an universal law, indeed, whatever, whether fixed or movable, belongs to all men equally and in common is the property for the moment of him who occupies it; but when he relinquishes the occupation, the property goes with it. Stable ownership is the gift of social law, and is given late in the progress of society." 
.
"The earth is given as a common stock for man to labor and live on. If for the encouragement of industry we allow it to be appropriated, we must take care that other employment be provided to those excluded from the appropriation. If we do not, the fundamental right to labor the earth returns to the unemployed... It is not too soon to provide by every possible means that as few as possible shall be without a little portion of land. The small landholders are the most precious part of a state."
.
====
.
And finally vedas say 
.
aham rashtrim vasunam sangamani" 
.
i.e. I the nation own all the elements of earth !!
.
====
.
IOW, MRCM = DDMRCAM only is procedural part. The concept has been age old.
.

Decreasing use of unaccounted cash and thus decreasing taxes on honest tax payers (28-mar-2015) No.10

March 28, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152683832546922

Decreasing use of unaccounted cash and thus decreasing taxes on honest tax payers.
.
Accounted cash when buyer B pays seller S, S does declare it as his income, while buyer B may or may not declare it as his expense. A payment made via bank using cheque or credit card is always accounted because bank is witness. So seller S cant deny.
.
Now many persons' all income is all cheque. But often they withdraw cash, and give it to seller S, and S will not report it as income and not pay taxes. So govt is forced to raise taxes on honest tax payers. This is how unaccounted cash transfers increase burden in on honest tax payers.
.
So how can we allow cash payments, and also ensure that cash payments do get properly accounted? IMO, following system can work 
.
1. buyer B will option to give his id to seller S , and S will put it on receipt or need not. When payment is done by card or cheque, buyer B's tax-id will automatically come on recipient,
.
2. say buyer B had paid Rs X
.
3. say seller S obtained Rs Y of revenue in whole FY = Financial Year and paid taxes of Rs T. 
.
4. Then next year, buyer B will get tax credit for 50% * X * T / Y 
.
5. If seller S doesnt report the id of B, then B cannot complain (the remedy for B is to use card or use trusted sellers).
.
IOW, say a person got salary of Rs 10 lakhs. He paid taxes of Rs 2.5 lakhs. And he spent Rs 3 lakhs using cash for check via various sellers. Say some sellers didnt report his expenditure with his id and some sellers did. Say Rs 2 lakhs of his expenditure was reported with his id to 100 sellers S1 to S100 , and expenses were X1 to X100. And say taxes they paid in that FY was T1 to T100., and their total incomes were Y1 to Y100. 
.
Then next year, tax credit buyer B will get will be 
.
50% * [ (X1 * T1 / Y1) + (X2 * T2 / Y2) + .... + (X100 * T100 / Y100)
.
To give an example in numbers, say buyer spent Rs 300000 with 4 sellers S1, S2, S3 and S3 and he bought goods worth Rs 50000 , Rs 50000, Rs 100000 and Rs 10000 from them. 
.
Say S4 didnt report B's Ids. So B wont gain on S4's tax credits.
.
Say S1 made losses and paid no taxes. So buyer B wont gain anything from S1
.
Say S2 and S2 made total sale of 1 crore and 2 crore. And taxes they paid were Rs 5 lakhs and Rs 8 lakhs.
.
Then tax credit B will get from S1 = 50% * (5 lakhs / 1 crore ) * Rs 50000 = 50% * 5% * Rs 50000 = Rs 12500
.
And tax credit B will get from S1 = 50% * (5 lakhs / 1 crore ) * Rs 50000 = 50% * 5% * Rs 50000 = Rs 1250
.
And tax credit B will get from S2 = 50% * (8 lakhs / 2 crore ) * Rs 100000 = 50% * 4% * Rs 100000 = Rs 2000
.
So next year, buyer B will have to pay Rs 1250 + Rs 2000 = Rs 3250 less tax.
.
IOW, tax credit's incentive will make a buyer use card \ cheque as far as possible. This will reduce tax evasion and thus reduce excess tax on honest tax payer.
.
======
.
How US elitemen reduced unaccounted cash by .
.
(1) ensuing that a large number of people are into debt !! This forces then to use card. And so seller's income does get registered. 
.
(2) by giving low interest loans to large corporations ; when a large corporations take amounts from 1000s or lakhs of customers, they take it via their employees such cash register clerks ; so if cash isnt registered then employees may rip-off , and so cash registration is streamlined
.
(3) rigging stock markets which enable large companies to get more capital 
.
(4) jury trials on tax evasions.
.
Option (4) is IMO good. The other options are IMO unsustainable i.e. they improve tax collection but weaken smaller employees.So I dont support them.
.

ArKe = AAP = PB = YoYa have ensured that for next 10 years, people will pay NO attention to anyone except Congress , BJP and NO one else (28-mar-2015) No.9

March 28, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152683949236922

ArKe = AAP = PB = YoYa have ensured that for next 10 years, people will pay NO attention to anyone except Congress , BJP and NO one else !!!
.
Previously, people didnt vote for newcomer, but at least heard what newcomer said, and then took valid points forward,
,
Now people will NOT even hear newcomers !!! 
.
AAP has stabilized corrupt rule of Congress / BJP .

The nation is losing billipns of activist-hours due to constant paidmedia coverage of petty phone talks of ArKe (28-mar-2015) No.9

March 28, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152683990311922

The nation is losing billipns of activist-hours due to constant paidmedia coverage of petty phone talks of ArKe ; 
.
because REAL issues that ArKe / PB / YoYa opposed the proposal to print Right to Recall Janlokpal clauses in the Janlokpal draft and wasted 3 years of activists are getting sidelined.
.
We must ask ALL activists to focus on the FACTS that ArKe wasted time of people in the name of Right to Recall (which he promised in apr-2011 and never gave draft even till today) .
.
And we should not waste time on petty phone talks.

As we RIGHTLY blame Jawaharlal Ghazi , Duratma Gandhi, Sardar Patel et al (28-mar-2015) No.8

March 28, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152684222671922

As we RIGHTLY blame Jawaharlal Ghazi , Duratma Gandhi, Sardar Patel et al . But whom do we blame for ill fate of Mahamta Batukeshwar Dutt. My point is --- over 95% of activists / voters didnt care whether freedom fighters die or rot in hell. REASON?
.
As things say, Rastrapita Mahatma Subhashchandra Bose was alive in Russia. And most likely, he died a tragic death, And it appears that Jawaharlal Ghazi, Duratma Gandhi, Sardar Patel , Shyama Prasad Mukherjee and many apex leaders knew about and decided to keep it secret fo their political gains. We can rightly blame all apex leaders.
.
But whom else we blame for freedom fighters who were OPENLY rotting in poverty due to physical and mental tourtures they had faced in priison, which made them unemployable?
.
Pls google Mahatma Batukeshwar Dutt,.
.
There were several 10000s like him.
.
.
And there were 1000s of soldiers of Azad Hindi Fauz who due to injury etc were living in poverty.
.
It was only in 1972 that Devi Indira created Freedom Fighter Pension scheme and also recognized Azad Hind Fauz soldiers as Freedom Fighters
.
IOW, whole nation --- almost all activists as well as citizens --- ignored 100000s of freedom fighters, their widows, their family members etc.
.
Reason AFAIS is ---- vyaktivaadi andhbhakti aka vyaktipuja !!! The activists in India have MUCH HIGHER tendency to become andbhagat of one person. And that person spends all his time in his promotion and them serving apex persons he depends on. And so all lakhs of activists end up giving ZERO focus on all other issues.
.
All in all, it is really sad that all freedom fighters were completely ignored. And lets at least thank Devi Indira Amma that she started Freedom Fighter Pension scheme and gave formal recognition to Azad Hind Fauz soldiers.
.
And unless activists stop this vyaktivaadi andhbhakti aka vyaktipuja , the problem will go on and on and on.

While CoBhApSwaRa-activists are busy with neta-pooja and slogan shouting (29-mar-2015) No.5

March 29, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152685560326922

While CoBhApSwaRa-activists are busy with neta-pooja and slogan shouting , and AAPians have evolved to fist-fights and mud slinging, we at RRG are making two-person conversation status posts on our fb walls.
.
We at Right to Recall Group arent brave enough to do slogan shouting. And we arent energetic to take morning walks at shakha either. And like AAP, we surely dont have strength to do fist fighting and throw mud. And head is too weak to wear a cap anyway !!
.
In "two person conversation status posts" , only two persons say A and B question-answer each other. And everyone interested can read, And say C has something to say, then C will write on (A-C) status post OR (B-C) status post OR both. 
.
This helps activists in understanding existing laws, proposed law-drafts campaign method etc.
.
And then each activist makes a notes with links to these status.
.
I request ALL recallists to open such status posts for fellow activists as well as those who want to know about RTR-drafts 
.

The central fight in AAP is --- who should decide who would give MLA / MLA / Corporation / Panchayat tickets (29-mar-2015) No.4

March 29, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152685585861922

The central fight in AAP is --- who should decide who would give MLA / MLA / Corporation / Panchayat tickets !! I request all volunteers to give DRAFTS that they think a good party can follow UNDER EXISTING LAWS.
.
Congress / BJP etc solved the problem by saying "high command" will decide. And high command works by keeping assorted desi - videshi elitemen and oligarchs in loop. The activists and voters at large think that high command decide and senior leaders have some say and dont know much about control foreigners exert on candidate selection. 
.
AAP was a 100% dishonest attempt to cover the issue. ArKe , YoYa, PB etc all lied that volunteers will vote and decide candidates, where as each one only wanted his pet men to become candidates. .
.
Why does YoYa want to become National Convener? And why is Arke not willing to give away that post? Because as per election commission rules, the National Convener or National President are the FINAL authority to decide who will get the party symbol aka party symbol. 
.
So all fist fight you see in AAP is all about "who will give ticket for MP , MLA etc elections " !!!
.
So I request ALL volunteers to give COMPLETE drafts, on YOUR FB wall to select MLA candidates, and post link here. The draft should start with basic terms such as voter , booth (collection of some 500-800 voters) and MUST avoid subjective terms like ward (because in ahmedabad, ward has 80000 voters while in Mumbai, they have lot less and in some smaller cities, ward only has a few thousand voters). 
.
And if they use term like "party member", then they should define how a voter can become party member and how he can be removed. 
.
Pls put ONLY link to YOUR status post having DRAFT to decide MLA candidate. Pls no other comments here
.

Worst crimes in Ramayan was done by Ravana. Ravan should have outrightly demanded apology (29-mar-2015) No.3

March 29, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152685768436922

Worst crimes in Ramayan was done by Ravana. Ravan should have outrightly demanded apology or fought war with Ram for cutting nose / ears of Surpankha. And his revenge for Surpankha's injury was with Ram and not Sita
.
But Ram's follies should be see as well. First, Ram should have resigned from kingship , make Laxman the King, and not abandoned Sita. Ram said that "public opinion was against Sita's staying as Queen", but King's responsibility to honor public opinion ends after resignation. And after resignation, he is private citizen, and only laws, and NOT opinions, apply. IOW, Ram had option of resigning and NOT abandoning Sita. IMO, it was criminal of him that he decided NOT to resign and instead abandon Sita. I wonder why till date, no critic said that "Ram should have resigned and not abandoned Sita".
.
The third biggest fault was of Laxman and Ram in cutting nose \ ears of Surpankha, sister of Ravan. There was no need. Laxman had already handcuffed Surpankha. She was a prisoner. And inflicting cruel punishment on a prisoner, that too a woman, is a crime, unless that person tries to repeat a crime. Ram / Laxman should have handed over handcuffed Surpankha to Ravan with warning that if she tried to harm anyone again, the consequences will be worse. Cutting nose etc was criminal.
.
Also, forth biggest fault was of Ram too ---- he refused to marry Surpankha. This is IMPORTANT. No Ramayan would have started if Ram had simpky agreed to marry Surpankha. No nose cutting, no abduction, no war, no public opinion to abandon Sita --- nothing would have happened if Ram had agreed to marry Surpankha in first place. Back then, polygamy was legal and a norm. And so refusal to marry was taken as insult by Surapnkha. Ram could have agreed to marry Sita with condition made with Ravan / Surpankha that only son of Sita will have kingdom. Back then, such conditions were common.In fact, this fault of Ram is central fault to whole bloodshed. If Ram had married Surpankha, no damage would have happened.
.
Then there is long list --- Ram's killing Bali was criminal ; Vibhishana was traitor etc etc and there is looooong list.
.
But one thing is shocking to me is that every Ramayan critic noticed ALL faults I have mentioned --- but none have noticed Ram's fault that he didnt resign and he refused to marry Surpankha !!
.
I dont know why no one before me noticed these faults of Ram !!
.
====
.
Another thing I noticed in H40 aka "Hanuman Chalisa" is that Tulasidas says that
.
1. if a person is doing 'ram ke kaam' i.e.good deeds then Hanumanji will help him
.
2. And Tulsida later says "asht sidhhi nau nidhi ke daata" i.e. Hanumanji, as I interpret this shloka, will try to get (8 Sidhies + 9 Nidhies + Sidhi + Nidhi ) = 19 wives or GFs , to someone who is doing "raam ke kaam" i.e. good deeds. !!! (please google on 8 sidhi and 9 nidhi ) . Again, this is my interpretation of H40. I wonder why no one ever noticed this till date.
.

The proposed WT = wealth law draft is to collect a wealth tax on land, construction, gold, shares, bonds, cash holdings (29-mar-2015) No.2

March 29, 2015

https://www.facebook.com/mehtarahulc/posts/10152686291831922

The proposed WT = wealth law draft is to collect a wealth tax on land, construction, gold, shares, bonds, cash holdings etc . The wealth tax will be about (1% per year of value of (wealth minus basic wealth deductions) ) minus income tax paid, minus other taxes paid minus other contributions and minus wealth tax credit accumulated over past years).
.
Dear citizens of India ,
.
My claim is that the proposed WT-MITMSC = Wealth Tax Minus Income Tax paid Minus Several Credits , will reduce the land prices, and will also reduce speculation in share markets. Reduction in land prices will reduce the amount a person has to spend in buying house or rents, and will increase his incomes minus rent. Reduction in land price will increase business and factories and will reduce unemployment. And it will increase income tax. And the reduction in land price will also reduce the problem of land acquisition.

=====

Pls take a look at the proposed law-draft. For explanation, you can search on FB for Right to Recall Group activists in your city. You can call \ meet them and they will explain the clauses to you. After explanations , if you support this law-draft, then please send following order to MP via SMS.
.
=========== start of order to be sent to MP via SMS ==========
.
Dear MP , I order you to print the law-draft mentioned inhttp://tinyurl.com/WealthTaxIndia
.
======= end of sms text ====
.
Dear MP,
.
If you have received the link to this law-draft then it is an order from YOUR voter , and NOT this author, to print the following law-draft in Gazette
.
===== start of the law-draft ====
.
section-1 : Basic definitions
.
(1.1) The word citizen in this draft would mean a registered adult voter
.
(1.2) The word land in this draft will include all plots, agricultural land and flats, offices, buildings, ownership over a plot created by owning a consutruction. And the word flat in this draft will include all construction --- apartments , bungalows , offices, buildings, warehouses, industrial shades and all other constructions.
.
section-2 : Main officers and their staff , offices
.
(2.1) ( instruction to PM )
.
The PM will appoint an officer titled as NWTO = National Wealth Tax Officer to collect wealth tax. The citizens of India may replace him using Right to Recall NWTO clauses listed in RTR-NWTO section
.
(2.2) ( instruction to NWTO . PM , MPs , citizens )
.
NWTO will prepare guidelines and give requirements of funds for running his offices across India. The guidelines will come into effect after PM prints them in Gazette or after MPs pass them as legislation or after citizens approve them using clauses given in the TCP-section of this draft
.
(2.3) ( instruction to NWTO )
.
NWTO will recruit existing officers from Central Govt or any State Govt , after approval of their respective heads. NWTO will appoint one SWTO = State Wealth Tax Officer , one DWTO = District Wealth Tax Officer per District, and appoint one TWTO = Tahsil Wealth Tax Officer per Tahsil. They will all work under Central Govt under NWTO .
.
section-3 : Guidelines to make wealth tax rules and change wealth tax rules
.
(3.1) Parliament may amend this wealth tax laws as necessary. PM too may make rules and amend the rules under this law using GNs as needed.
.
(3.2) NWTO may issue circulars to calculate and collect wealth tax as needed.
.
(3.3) When a circular is issued by NWTO, it will be sent to all DWTO across India who will summon 12 Jurors at random. DWTO will explain the circular to the Jurors and Jurors may ask any CA or any person to present his views on the circular. And if majority of Jurors across India oppose the circular, then NWTO may or need not resign , and may or need not cancel the circular. His decision will be final.
,
(3.4) The citizens may issue a circular using TCP-clauses given in TCP-section of this draft.
.
section-4 : Filing wealth tax return
.
(4.1) Each wealth owner , except Indian citizens who have wealth below basic deductions. All foreign entities, all companies and all trust must file wealth tax returns.
.
(4.2) The wealth tax return must be filed within 210 days after closing of financial year, and must be filed within 30 days after income tax return is filed.
.
(4.3) The tax payer can use his PAN-ID or Adhar-ID to file his wealth disclosure. If he doesn’t have any of the two IDs, then he must obtain one ID within 3 months after this law is printed in Gazette.
.
(4.4) For HUF, the Karta can file separate return for HUF in which HUF will get no basic deductions, or can add HUF’s wealths with his wealth, and file a return.
.
section-5 : Basic deduction from wealth tax
.
This section has basic deduction of human entities below age of 60 years. .
.
(5.1) The basic deductions for all non-person entities , such as companies, trusts, HUFs etc will be zero. The basic deductions for foreigner persons will be zero.
.
(5.2) The basic deductions for persons above age of 60 years will be twice than basic deductions listed below. And for those above age of 80 years will be 4 times the basic deductions. The basic deductions of widows and widowers will be also twice. However, for widows or widowers of above age of 60 years, it will be only 2 times and not four times; and for widows or widowers of above age of 80 years, it will be only 4 times and not eight times.
,
(5.3) Unused deductions can be transferred to a family member. For definition and eligibility of family members, please see later sections

(5.4) the non-agricultural plots - 25 sqmt per person, and unused deductions can be transferred to a family member .
.
(5.5) construction above 50 sqmt per person, and unused deduction can be transferred to a family member.
.
(5.6) agricultural land below 2 acres per family member ; and unused deduction can be transferred to a family member
.
(5.7) gold \ silver \ diamonds \ precious stones \ jewelry worth below Rs 50000 per male person and below Rs 2.5 lakh per female person ; and unused deduction can be transferred head of family.
.
(5.8) vehicles worth below Rs 1 lakh per person ; and unused deduction can be transferred to a family member.
.
(5.9) all shares \ bonds \ debentures owned in companies , in which companies are paying wealth tax on their shares \ bonds \ debentures , will be exempt from share owner
.
(5.10) shares \ bonds \ debentures worth below Rs 100,000 , owned in companies , in which companies are paying wealth tax on their shares \ bonds \ debentures ; this deduction isn’t transferable
.
(5.11) cash-in-hand below Rs 1 lakh per family member ; ; and unused deduction can be transferred to a family member.
.
(5.12) furniture, electrical items, electronic items, hardware, painting, art forms below Rs 3 lakhs per family member; ; and unused deduction can be transferred to a family member
.
(5.13) wealth outside India is not exempt unless person is returning NRI in which case wealth of Rs 10 lakhs per person will be exempt ; and unused deduction can be transferred to family member
.
(5.14) intellectual property such software, brandname, patents, copyrights, will be exempt from wealth tax for person as well as non-person entities
.
section-6 : WTC = Wealth tax credits for previous years
.
Several taxes and other payments made in past 4 years will become wealth tax credit.
.
(6.1) WTC will be calculated for each financial year separately. It will be labeled as WTC-AY-YYYY-(YYYY+1) i.e. WTC for Financial Year starting 1-apr-YYYY to 31-mar-(YYYY+1).
.
(6.2) WTC will be calculated for 4 years before this wealth tax law starts.
.
{ Explanation :
.
FY = Financial Year , AY = Assessment Year.
.
Say wealth tax starts from FY 1-apr-2016 to 31-mar-2017 i.e. AY-2017-2018. and onwards.
.
Then WTC will be calculated for four previous years
.
WTC-AY-2013-2014 : wealth tax credit generated out of taxes paid for FY 1-apr-2012 to 31-mar-2013 i..e AY 1-apr-2013 to 31-mar-2014
.
WTC-AY-2014-2015 : wealth tax credit generated out of taxes paid for FY 1-apr-2013 to 31-mar-2014 , AY 1-apr-2014 to 31-mar-2015
.
WTC-AY-2015-2016 : wealth tax credit generated out of taxes paid for FY 1-apr-2014 to 31-mar-2015 , AY 1-apr-2015 to 31-mar-2016
.
WTC-AY-2016-2017 : wealth tax credit generated out of taxes paid for FY 1-apr-2015 to 31-mar-2016 , AY 1-apr-2016 to 31-mar-2017
}
..
(6.3) pro-rata income tax paid on non-salary income in an AY will be WTC for that AY
.
(6.4) pro-rata 50% income tax paid on salary income will be WTC
.
{ Explanation : if salary income is say Rs X and non salary income is say Rs Y and total tax paid was Rs T, then of tax from salary income will be Rs T * X / (X + Y) and tax paid from non-salary income will be Rs T * Y / (X + Y)
}
.
(6.5) wealth tax \ service tax \ excise \ vat \ octroi \ cst \ local body taxes \ pay roll tax\ professional tax\ municipal property tax and all taxes paid to central govt (except customs) , state govt or local govt in that AY as stated in the return will become WTC for that AY. Customs duty paid will not be counted towards WTC.
.
(6.6) for every employee , (0% of salary below Rs 2 lakhs, 5% of salary between Rs 2 lakhs and Rs 5 lakhs, 10% of salary between Rs 5 lakhs and Rs 10 lakhs ; and 15% of salary over Rs 10 lakhs) will be added to WTC
.
{ Explanation :
Say an employer had 3 employees and salaries paid in an AY were Rs 150,000/- , Rs 260,000/-, Rs 600,000/- and Rs 1200,000/- . The WTC from employee’s salaries will be Rs 0, Rs 3000 , Rs 25000 , Rs 95000/- respectively . Total WTC from employees’ salary will be sum of these four numbers.
}
.

(6.7) for every employer, 15% of the employer side PF paid by the employer will be added to WTC of employer
.
(6.8) The penalties on unpaid or late-paid taxes will be fully included. Only 50% of the interest paid due to non-payment or late-payment will be included.
.
(6.9) WTC will not consider actual date of payment but only the amount due in each FY or corresponding AY
.
(6.10) To claim and correct WTC of a year, a person will have at most 2 years after ending of that AY. For first 4 years’ WTC, it will be till 3 years after the wealth tax law implementation starts.
.
(6.11) In case of dispute on WTC amount, the govt records will be deemed final in case of discrepancy. The Jurors may revise the amount after a trial
.
section-7 : Wealth tax credits for subsequent years
.
For the years after passing the law, the Wealth Tax Credits for an AY consist of following
.
(7.1) income tax paid on non-salary income
.
(7.2) 50% of income tax on salary income
.
(7.3) all other taxes due to central govt (except customs), state govt and local govt , such as in that AY ; penalties and interest paid, and fines paid on taxes will not be included
.
(7.4) 15% of salaries paid by payee a/c cheque , or cash , if employee enters cash salary his cashbook maintained at the bank or mentions in his income tax return
.
(7.5) 15% of PF paid by the employer
.
(7.6) number of service takers multiplied by Rs 500
.
section-8 : Calculation of wealth tax
.
(8.1) LC = Land and construction will be valued at circle rate or purchase price, which ever is higher. There will be no depreciation on land and depreciation on construction will be 5% a year and indexation increase would apply.
.
(8.2) M = Machinery , vehicles, hardware will be valued at purchase price. and 10% annual depreciation and no indexation will apply. Furniture will be valued at purchase price and 5% annual depreciation and indexation will apply
.
(8.3) GS = Gold, silver, metals, diamonds and precious stone will be valued at annual average market price
.
(8.4) SP = (a) If company is paying wealth tax on shares, then taxable share price will be average market capitalization during the year minus value of land, construction, precious metals gold, precious stones (b) if owner is paying wealth tax then it will be average share price across the year (c) either company or owner but not both will pay wealth tax on share
.
(8.5) In each case, applicable basic deductions can be subtracted.
.
(8.6) Wealth tax payable will be 1% of (LC + MF + GS + SP ) minus applicable basic deductions.
.
(8.7) If wealth tax is negative then it will become wealth tax credit for that AY
.
(8.8) if wealth tax payable for that year is positive, then oldest WTC will be used to lower it. And when all WTC are exhausted , the tax payer will be required to pay the wealth tax.
.
(8.9) In case of inability to pay, the tax payer can request locking of his property, and in that case interest of 9% per year will apply. However, the value of property must be at least twice the outstanding tax
.
section-6 : Eligibility to become family member
.
(6.1) For the purpose of wealth tax, an individual can register himself as solitaire i.e. alone or part of family. which ever suits him best.
.
(6.2) One person cannot be member of two families. Persons registered as solitaire cant be member of any family. Non-person entity or foreigner cant be member of family for wealth tax purposes.
.
(6.3) A family cannot have more than 12 members. The family member must not have wealth above Rs 25 crore , not counting land and constructions.
.
(6.4) Family will consist of Head of the family, who can be male or female above 18 years of age.
.
(6.5) The spouses of Head can become member of the family.
.
(6.6) The children can become member of the family
.
(6.7) The parents and parents-in-law can become member of the family
.
(6.8) Children of son / daughter can become member of family , but only if son / daughter is also member of the family.
.
(6.9) The children of grand children cannot become member of the family
.
(6.10) Unmarried or divorced sister of the Head can be member of family. Brother below 18 years can become member of the family.

(6.11) Children of brother or sister cannot become member of family
.
(6.12) No one except above can become member of family
.
(6.13) If a person has more than 4 children, then only 4 can be part of family for wealth tax purposes.
.
(6.14) If a person wants to form family for wealth tax purpose, then he will need to register his family members by personally appearing at Patwari = Talati = Village Officer. And the members too will have too appear at office of any Patwari in India and acknowledge it. For minors, permission of both parents will be needed.
.
(6.15) The family members can transfer their basic deductions amongst themselves
.
(6;.15) The family members cannot transfer their WTC to anyone
.
section-Jury-Trial : Jury Trial for wealth tax disputes
.
(J.1) ( instruction to NWTO , all tax payers)
.
Wherever there is dispute between NWTO or his officer and tax payer, NWTO or his officers will form a CCA = Committee of Chartered Accountants and form a Jury to decide the case. This section gives rules of formation of CCA and the Jury.
.
(J.2) ( instruction to NWTO )
.
NWTO will appoint a Jury Administrator for each District called as DJA = District Jury Administrator, and one Jury Administrator for each State called as SJA = State Jury Administrator, and one Jury Administrator for India called as NJA = National Jury Administrator
.
(J.3) ( instruction to NJA , SJA , DJA, all WT officers , all tax payers)

(J.3.1) A tax dispute between a tax payer and tax officer will be filed in district in which tax payer is voter of or is resident of or has registered offices, in that order. If the tax payer or tax officer wants to change the venue to a district in same state, then may get order from SJA or State High Court. And if either of the two wish to change venue to a district in India outside the State , then he may get order from NJA or Supreme Court.
.
(J.3.2) For every tax dispute in district, the DJA = District Jury Administrator will randomly select 3 to 10 CAs from a list of CAs who have agreed to provide assistance in cases. The CAs selected must be between the age of 30 years and 55 years, and must have 5 years of experience as CA.
.
(J.2.3) DJA will randomly select voters from voter list of India between age of 30 and 55 years. The person must not have appeared in any Jury in past 10 years and must not have faced any conviction in past.
.
(J.3.3) Number of Jurors – The number of Jurors will be at least 12 and at most 1500. The Jurors . number Jurors will be 12, if the wealth tax evasion as claimed by WTO = Wealth Tax Officer is below Rs 10 lakh. And there will 1 extra Jurors for every Rs 10 lakhs of wealth tax evasion as claimed by WTO. The highest size will be 1500 Jurors
.
(J.3.4) Location of Jurors --- The Jurors will be selected from Districts whose District Courts are linked via video conferencing to districts where trial is being run. In the district isn’t connected with any district via video conferencing, then all Jurors will be from District where the case is filed.
.
(J.3.5) Disputes of valuation of wealth – if the dispute is only over valuation of land, then dispute will resolved by the Jurors in that district. The number of Jurors will be 12 + plus 1 Juror per Rs 10 lakh of difference in valuation , with maximum of 1500 Jurors. However , DWTO, SWTO or NWTO may ask for change of venue to decide the valuation of the land.
.
(J.3.6) Appeal against judgment of of District Jurors can be filed with Jurors or Judges in State High Court and later with Jurors or Judges in Supreme Court as decided by other prevailing laws
.
section-RTR-NWTO : Right to Recall NWTO
.
(RTR.1) ( instruction to Cabinet Secretary , Union Govt or officer he deputes )
.
If any citizen of India wishes to become NWTO , and he appears in person or via a lawyer with affidavit before the Cabinet Secretary, then the Secretary would accept his candidacy for NWTO after taking filing fee same as deposit amount for MP election.
.
(RTR 2) (instruction to Talati , or Talati’s Clerks)
.
If a citizen of that district comes in person to Talati’s office, pays Rs 3 fee , and approves at most five persons for the NWTO position, then the Talati would enter his approvals in the computer and would him a receipt with his voter-id#, date/time and the persons he approved.
.
(RTR.3) ( instruction to Talati )
.
The Talati will put the preferences of the citizen on PM's website with citizen’s voter-ID number and his preferences
.
(RTR.4) (instruction to Talati)
.
If a the citizen comes to cancel his Approvals, the Talati will cancel one of more of his approvals without any fee
.

(RTR.5) (instruction to Cabinet Secretary)
.
On every 5th of month, the CS may publish Approval counts for each candidate as on last date of the previous month.
.
(RTR.6) (instruction to PM )
.
If a candidate gets approval of over 51% of ALL registered citizen-voters (ALL, not just those who have filed their approval) in a district, then PM may or need not expel the existing NWTO and may or need not appoint the person with highest approval count as NWTO . The decision of PM will be final
.
section-TCP : TCP-clauses
.
(TCP.1) ( instruction to District Collector )
.
if any citizen wants a change in this law-draft, he may submit an affidavit at Collector’s office and Collector or his clerk will post the affidavit on the website of Prime Minister for a fee of Rs 20/- per page.
.
(TCP.2) (instruction to Talati or Patwari)
.
If any citizens want to register his opposition to this law-draft or any section or wants to register YES-NO to any affidavit submitted in above clause, and he comes to Talati’s office with voter-ID and pays Rs 3 fee, Talati will enter YES/NO and give him a receipt. The YES-NO will be posted on the website of the Prime Minister.
..
(TCP.3) (instruction to Talati or Patwari)
.
If any citizens want to register his opposition to this law-draft or any section or wants to register YES-NO to any affidavit submitted in above clause, and he comes to Talati’s office with voter-ID and pays Rs 3 fee, Talati will enter YES/NO and give him a receipt. The YES-NO will be posted on the website of the Prime Minister.
.